Marty Gerber
  • Blog
  • About
  • Praise
  • Contact
  • TNB Home

Writing on my mind

what’s “creative”? what’s “nonfiction”? what’s in a name? take your choice

2/13/2015

0 Comments

 
Picture
Once upon a time in the world of writing, a work could be “fact” (e.g., Gibbon’s History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire”) or “fiction” (Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar). But over time, suspects came along for whom life was somewhat fuzzier than this (Truman Capote and Tom Wolfe to name a couple of esteemed practitioners).

 So what’s in the middle? It’s this thing called “creative nonfiction.”

And the definition? The parameters? Well, that shifts back into this sphere of fuzziness referred to above.

Rule No. 1 is that you can’t make things up. So that’s what you start with: facts. This earns you the freedom to fancy up those facts with “the techniques of fiction.” The antithesis is the encyclopedia; the model is the novel, or at least the short story.

Build your tale around scenes (which is the basis of “show, don’t tell” anyway). Dialogue, description, detail all become bricks that add the “creative” to your structure. But what’s become the essential element is point of view—the writer’s individual “voice,” unique and unlike the way anyone else would tell the same story.

Done right, what results is vivid, compelling, a work as enthralling as the best fiction. But as we sit hunched over the keyboard—immersed in information, struggling to shape it—that first step we take on the slippery slope can be mighty hard to notice. Of course, there’s no license to lie. But how seductive the little white kind can be! (I’m only changing the quote a bit to make the point he intended. I’m simply clarifying what she must have been thinking.)

It’s been a long time now since quantum physics taught us that data can’t be gathered independent of the person doing the gathering. But if I, the writer, need to be some part of what I’m writing, what part is the right part? Just because the fellow I interviewed is a sleaze and an asshole, I don’t get a permit to flatly say that. Instead, I need to subtly guide my reader to the same conclusion through selective inclusion, exclusion, editing (manipulation? distortion?) of his words. That’s being “creative,” right?

Recent years have been generous with sad examples of writers convinced by hubris that all it took to make their fictions “fact” was to label it that. But for each one of those unmasked, how many still fool us?

Back a bunch of decades ago when the newspaper business was giving me paychecks, its Bible was “objectivity.” Eventually folks realized humans were as capable of achieving this as reaching the moon by flapping their arms. Then the mantra became “fairness”: We lay out all the relevant facts and opinions, and readers will magically assemble from them the real-world knowledge they need. It sounds like a wonderful idea—simply do an easy values-otomy on the disseminators of those facts and opinions, a careful surgical incision to remove all personal attitudes toward the information as well as all desire and power to make judgments. Sure gets my vote!

So where does this all leave us when we start a book of nonfiction, creative or otherwise? As readers, I’d hope it’s in the armchair of the skeptic while we turn those pages (physically or electronically), knowing the writer did her or his best in the doomed effort to transcend bias and imperfection. And as writers, we’re in exactly the same place as the people we see pushing the rock up that Sisyphean hill to give the world the gifts of peace, justice, and compassion: Likely to succeed or not, we’re all just doing what we have to.

This, I guess, is the inherent advantage fiction has over nonfiction: Fact doesn’t have to get in the way of truth. I’ve seen creative nonfiction called “the literature of reality,” and I like the phrase. Nevertheless, the idea of an absolute reality equally perceivable to everyone on Planet Earth seems pretty fictitious to me. But your reality and my reality and his reality and her reality and those other folks’ reality just might add up to a semblance of the way things actually are that’s as close as we can humanly come—if each of us is alert and aware enough to see it. Given the limits the metaphorical God built into our species, it’s probably the best we can do.


0 Comments
    Picture

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    Marty Gerber is the editor and co-owner of Terra Nova Books. He established the publishing company in partnership with his son, Scott, in 2012 after working as a freelance editor of books and professional journals since the early 1990s. Before that, he was a newspaper writer and editor for many years, both with some of the nation’s leading dailies and as the founder of startups in Albuquerque and Santa Fe, N.M. He also has taught journalism at New York University and the University of Arizona, and has ghostwritten two books and written two others as himself.

    Archives

    April 2016
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    April 2014


    RSS Feed


    Twitter
    Picture
    Facebook
    Picture

    Categories

    All
    Amazon
    Amazon Kindle
    Arnon
    Author
    Ayana Mathis
    Best First Novel
    Best-Seller List
    Best-selling
    Beyond The Will Of God
    Bias
    Blurbs
    Book Review
    Book Title
    Brain
    Catherine McKenzie
    Competition
    Contemporary Fiction
    Creative
    Creative Nonfiction
    Customer
    Dallas Cowboys
    Daniel Mendelsohn
    Data Mining
    David Biddle
    Discovery
    Don't Tell
    EBooks
    Ego
    Elena Ferrante
    Eliza Gabbert
    Essential Good
    Five-star
    Future Of Books
    Gary Shteyngart
    Goddess
    Grunberg
    Hachette
    Heart Of Darkness
    Hubris
    Independent
    Indie Author
    Interview
    Juliet
    Kindle
    Koan
    Kowtow
    Literary Fiction
    Literature Of Reality
    Lyric Essay
    Maggie Shipstead
    Megan Stielstra
    Miranda July
    Mohsin Hamid
    Netherlands
    Neuroscience
    New York Times
    Novelist
    Objectivity
    One-star
    Oyster
    Paris
    Pew
    Phone
    Point Of View
    Praise
    Print
    Print Books
    Profit
    Quantum Physics
    Reading Habits
    Review
    Revision
    Roadmap For Success
    Rose
    Scribd
    Self-published
    Self-publishing
    Shakespeare
    Show
    Siddhartha Deb
    Simon & Schuster
    Sisyphus
    Sweet
    Terra Nova Books
    The First Bad Man
    Time Keeps On Slipping Into The Future
    Title
    Track
    Turgid
    Walmart
    Writers Block
    Writing

Copyright 2014 - Marty Gerber   All Rights Reserved
Terra Nova Books